You are correct Nag, since neither Carl or Christian is on the board of OPEC, they cant do anything about fuel prices. Most people know that only oil companies and people on the other side of the Atlantic control fuel prices.
The question was, and I may not be totally exact word for word, but something like, "With gas approaching four dollars a gallon, and most people working in the valley, why should someone want to live here?"
My take on that is two fold:
1 . If someone is going to make the continuing investment to commute, what makes Maricopa a better place to live than somewhere close to work in the valley?
2 . What can you as a mayor do about bringing some of the high quality jobs from the valley down here?
The fuel part was just thrown in as a reason to ask the question, not the meat of the question itself.
Its like if I walked into a hairdresser in Houston and said, "With humidity approaching 80% most days, what can I do to keep my hair from flying all over the place?" I wouldnt expect an answer about the science of global weather patterns. I believe she refers to this question often because it is the most off-topic response he gave at the debate.