Hi TomH.
Your list was going well up until...
6. Diedrich can't keep appointments, can't finish projects that he's responsible for.
Please provide referenced examples. Thank you.
Easy to do...
There are many projects to choose from, but I'll go with the FOR Maricopa Food Bank Website. Carl was supposed to be the developer of the website, he got it started, but after waiting well over 9 months to get it finished, Wendy Webb had to finally take it away and give it to someone else to finish. It's took months for Wendy to even get Carl's attention long enough to get the keys to the website to the 2nd person to finish. Carl has done this on several projects.
I've even been told 1st hand on paid jobs where businesses had to give Carl the boot because he couldn't get their work done.
I know many of you are friends, and that's all cool, Carl is a nice guy. But you really need to separate your friendship from making a good decision for Maricopa.